Is the J-1 Visa Program at Risk?

I have been watching and questioning the firmness of one of the most important government programs on which our leisure industry relies for employment augmentation, the J-1 exchange visa program. This program is a non-immigrant visa platform for foreign nationals approved to participate in exchange visitor programs in the United States. It includes activities like teaching, studying, research, and those demonstrating special skills such as working in the leisure sectors including federal, state, and private parks.

The recent arrest of Mahmoud Khalil (on March 8th), a Palestinian activist and permanent resident who is involved in pro-Palestinian protests at Columbia University, has sparked significant debate regarding U.S. immigration policies and their potential impact on visa programs, including the J-1 Exchange Visitor Program.

Source:  KK Career Solution

Khalil, a graduate student at Columbia University's School of International and Public Affairs, was detained by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents at his university residence. Though holding a green card through his marriage to a U.S. citizen in 2022, Khalil was arrested due to his open support for Hamas, a designated terrorist organization. This arrest aligns with the Trump administration's intensified efforts to target individuals perceived as supporting terrorist groups.

To clarify further, the J-1 Visa Program facilitates cultural exchange by allowing foreign nationals to participate in work and study programs in the United States. The arrest of a permanent resident like Khalil has multiple ramifications and raises concerns about the security of immigration statuses, potentially deterring prospective J-1 applicants applying for short term stay. Why? Well, fears of increased scrutiny or deportation could lead to a decline in the program by participants, affecting various sectors reliant on J-1 visa holders, certainly our leisure operations.

By leisure industry, I am including hospitality, tourism, and recreation, all of which depends heavily on J-1 visa holders, especially during the peak and shoulder periods of the seasons. It was estimated that approximately 334,000 J-1 Visas were issued in 2024, an increase from the previous 6 years. In 2017, there was a slowdown, and a huge push to "Buy American and Hire American”, which was basically an executive branch order. These visa trimmings came at a time when there was ultra-high tension surrounding the topic of immigration, resulting in a general cutback to all immigration including J-1 exchange applicants. The program faced yet another setback in 2020, when the program was temporarily halted until 2021 due to Covid.

There is no official indication of a current slowdown, or possible cancellation of the J-1 Program, but the intensified enforcement actions against Khalil these past few days, as well as the ongoing protests, could create a chilling effect. Potential applicants may reconsider participation due to perceived risks, leading to a natural decline in program numbers. Additionally, if the administration expands its scrutiny to include exchange visitors, program sponsors might implement more stringent selection criteria (I doubt it), but it could possibly reduce some participation. Also, if a similar action like taken back in 2016-2017 happened, it could slow the process enough to create hiring/timing issues for seasonal park operators.

The arrest of Mahmoud Khalil emphasizes a shift in U.S. immigration enforcement, potentially influencing visa programs like the J-1…. again, too early to determine.

The leisure industry is already suffering from several years of severe labor shortages and high wages, which makes us more reliant on visa programs. Continuous communication and monitoring of potential policy changes, along with proactive engagement with our politicians, are essential to mitigate any adverse effects on our valuable cultural exchange programs and employment wellbeing. This is one program we do not want to lose.

Click here to read more observations.